Mario Kart 8 Deluxe Review

Mario Kart 8 Deluxe Review: Racing to the top

Mario Kart 8 Deluxe is the Nintendo Switch’s upgraded port of the stellar Mario Kart 8, DLC included. Unlike most ports to next generation consoles, this entry has some very significant updates, ranging from subtle to “Holy crap it has a real Battle Mode!” As such, this title should be treated as a new game, which is why we’re giving it a full review of its own.

New Battle Mode

Mario Kart 8 DeluxeMario Kart 8 for Wii U was a solid 9/10, with its only real, glaring flaws being its pathetic excuse for a Battle Mode, and the controversial “fire hopping” technique. We’re happy to report that both of those issues have been addressed. For starters, Battle mode has its own specific tracks now, 8 new tracks in total, a new Feather item that’s exclusive to battles, and five battle modes to choose from:

  • Balloon Battle: Compete by popping or stealing opponents’ balloons, whoever has popped the most when time runs out is the winner. Unlike early versions, players have an infinite number of balloons, but they lose points when they are sidelined and forced to restock.
  • Renegade Roundup: A mashup of Cops and Robbers and Pac-Man, The renegades drive around collecting coins for points, while the cop team tries to capture them with piranha plants. Captured players are held in a cell until freed by their teammates. The match ends if all renegades are captured, or time runs out.
  • Bob-omb Blast: All item boxes give 1-2 Bob-ombs, and a point is awarded every time a player blows up an opponent. The Bob-omb throwing mechanic is altered so that players can control distance to a much greater degree. Additionally, players cannot blow themselves up with their own Bob-ombs.
  • Coin Runners: Players scramble to collect coins, and the player with the most gold when time’s up is the winner. Players can find coins on the track or steal them by pelting opponents with items and collecting what they drop.
  • Shine Thief: It’s a mad dash to capture and hold the Shine Sprite for 20 seconds, a task that’s easier said than done, as the person holding the Shine Sprite gets a nice big target on their back and a noticeable reduction in speed.

Racing and General Improvements

Mario Kart 8 Deluxe Pink BoostWhile the new and improved Battle Mode is a blast, the traditional racing mode saw several notable changes as well, beyond the fix of fire hopping. Most noticeable is the addition of a second item slot, allowing two items to be held at once. Double item boxes have been added as well, which helps improve the strategic aspect of Mario Kart 8 Deluxe over its predecessor: Double item boxes almost always have less than optimal placement, so players must weight the benefits of the second item against the faster route.

Another nice change is the alterations made to acceleration. Before, spec points into acceleration would only have an effect at whole numbers, represented by a full bar on the character select status screen. Previously, a setup with 3.75 acceleration would accelerate at the same rate as a setup with 3.0 acceleration. Now each point counts. This allows for much greater variety in kart builds.

Splatoon’s Inklings (girl and boy, with three color variations each), Bowser Jr., Dry Bones, and King Boo all made it into the game as Deluxe exclusive characters. Speaking of Boos, the Boo item has now returned as well. There are tons of little touches and bonuses to go into, but we need to move on.

Multiplayer and Online

Mario Kart 8 Deluxe Split ScreenVisuals in Mario Kart 8 Deluxe are rendered at 1080p when docked, 720p when in handheld, and both modes look beautiful. The skipped frame glitch has been fixed, meaning the game will run at a perfect locked 60 fps in both modes. The multiplayer still locks at 30 fps when the screen is split for three and four player modes, but the two player split screen has been boosted up to 60 fps, so it’s a nice boost overall.

Mario Kart 8 Deluxe is a perfect game to sell the split joy-con multiplayer. The convenience of being able to detach the joy-cons and start a two player match of Mario Kart on the go, with literally no control sacrifice whatsoever, easily outweighs the fact they were not designed for adult male hands. Thankfully, the control layout took this into consideration and allows for the best possible distance between the stick and important face buttons.

Additionally, online has seen a pair of particularly nice changes, one via the game itself, and the other via the Nintendo Switch’s hardware design. Players can re-spec their karts in the online lobby between matches, which is a great quality of life change, and more obviously, the game is now portable. The Switch can be tethered to a smartphone to allow for online play wherever you go. We were initially skeptical at first, so we gave it a shot and it played like a dream, with no discernible issues or drops in an hour of use. It only used ~250MB/hour to boot, which is a reasonable amount of data to use for an hour of quality entertainment.

The biggest remaining issue with Mario Kart 8 Deluxe is that playing with friends has yet to be streamlined with a proper friend lobby. That may change with Nintendo’s future Switch compatible smartphone app, which they claimed would function as such, but it’s something that could have easily made it into the game itself.

CSG Case Summary

Mario Kart 8 Deluxe

  • Visuals: 10
  • Sound: 10
  • Controls: 10
  • Gameplay: 10
  • X-Factor: 8
Final Judgement: 10/10

Mario Kart 8 Deluxe is an excellent game that every Nintendo Switch owner should consider purchasing. Mario Kart 8 was a 9/10 experience, and Mario Kart 8 Deluxe is a vast improvement over the original. There’s really nowhere to go with the score but up.

[Edit: there was a typo in the article. I messed up when transcribing the score from my working document. X-Factor was always supposed to be an 8, not a 10. The overall score of 10/10 remains unaffected. Overall scores are rounded to the nearest whole number.]


If you would like to support my writing and future endeavors,  please feel free to check out my Patreon (Work in Progress) or my PayPal Tip Jar. If you want to be updated when new articles articles are posted, follow us on our social media accounts in the sidebar, or follow me personally @JamesAdamWynne

6 thoughts on “Mario Kart 8 Deluxe Review: Racing to the top”

  1. That’s crazy to give 10 of 10. The online playing with friends is a DISASTER. It literally took me and my friends 20 min of attempts to finally get in a room together. As a test I took the joycons off the mount to try racing and it was horrid. Not a knock on the game with that but hitting L and R triggers was tough. The game also gets frustrating and cheap. Race a perfect race then get hit with 5 red shells, a blue shell, and a lightning bolt with no defensive weapons. 7 out of 10 tops.

    1. Judging a game by its worst case scenario is poor form. I also had no issues online, though I did note the lack of friend lobby issue

      First thing to note about scores here, is that we use a 10 point, whole number system, not that it mattered much in this case. Second, 10/10 isn’t a perfect game, there are no perfect games. its an excessively great game, and typically a rare score. 2017 has been an atypically good year so far for 9’s and 10’s

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s